Preparing equipment for on-site balancing: a customer checklist
The engineer arrives with an instrument, not a repair crew. Everything they can get done in a shift depends on your preparation: whether the magnet holds on the support, whether the impeller is clean, who's authorized to press 'start,' and whether the machine can be stopped five times in a row. Visits fail not on the calculation, but on not being able to reach the correction plane — the location on the rotor where the correction weights go — without disassembly. Below is a single checklist and an honest list of the conditions under which the work gets postponed.
The single checklist: go through it the day before the visit
- Mechanics. Bearings with no critical play, feet bolted down, a frame with no cracks or loosened joints, the rotor not rubbing anywhere and turning smoothly.
- Cleanliness. The impeller, wheel, pulley or drum cleaned of build-up, dust and product in advance, not on the day of the work.
- Sensor mounting spots. A clean, flat spot prepared at each bearing housing: the magnet needs to seat on bare metal, not on paint over dirt.
- Tachometer marker. There's a place on the shaft or hub for the reflective marker, and the laser can see it from the tripod.
- Correction planes. You can reach the weight-installation points with the rotor stopped, without disassembling the machine.
- Hatches and guards. It's clear who removes the guard, who puts it back, and what paperwork covers that.
- A window for the runs. A window for 3–6 runs is agreed, with a full stop after each one until the rotor is completely still. All runs at the same operating mode.
- An operator. Someone authorized to start and stop the machine is on site, and won't be pulled onto another task an hour in.
- Work permit and lockout. Paperwork is arranged before the visit, and the lockout scheme is clear to everyone involved.
- Power and light. A 220 V outlet within 5–10 meters of the bearings, working light at the platform and at the correction planes.
- Tools and materials. Wrenches, a drill, plates and washers for the weights, bolted fasteners or a welder if the weights have to be welded on.
- Machine data. Nameplate speed, drive power, rotor mass, type of supports and foundation, repair and prior-balancing history.
- Photos and video. Shots of the rotor, both bearings and the correction planes, plus a short video of it running, with sound.
- A draft report. The machine's designation on your own scheme, measurement points, operating mode and the target vibration value.
The list looks long, but it takes a mechanic about an hour. One item out of these fourteen left undone usually costs you anywhere from half a shift to a full repeat visit.
Mechanical soundness: balancing doesn't substitute for repair
The correction calculation relies on the 'rotor — supports — foundation' system behaving linearly: double the unbalanced mass, and vibration doubles. The entire math of the influence-coefficient method rests on this assumption: the software calculates what correction weight to install, and where, from the machine's response to a trial weight. A worn-out bearing, a loose wheel fit on the shaft, or an unbolted frame breaks that linearity, and the instrument gets contradictory answers from the machine to the same input.
The simplest way to see this is through the stability of the readings. While the machine runs at a constant speed, the amplitude and phase of the running-speed component (the vibration at the rotor's rotating frequency; phase is its angle relative to the shaft marker) shouldn't drift by more than 10–15% over the measurement window. If the numbers are jumping, going further is pointless: the influence coefficient will come out random, and the weights will land in the wrong place.
A separate case is a machine that's simply standing on the floor or on shims, with no anchors. Under noticeable vibration, the unbalance force lifts the unit, the system's stiffness changes within a single run, and the result doesn't repeat from run to run. That kind of machine needs bolting down, not balancing.
Check one more thing by hand. Turn a horizontal-axis rotor 90° and let go. If it consistently turns back to the same position, the rotor has pronounced static unbalance: the heavy spot outweighs the rest and drops downward. That's not a reason to cancel the work, but it's useful for the engineer to know in advance: the first run on that kind of machine is done cautiously, at a reduced speed.
- Play in the bearings. Noticeable radial play, rumbling, knocking or overheating mean a repair is needed, not balancing.
- Fasteners and soft foot. All foot bolts are torqued, the shims are thick enough and don't compress, there's no gap under the foot.
- Frame and foundation. No cracks, no delaminated grout, no loosened anchors, no 'temporary' welded-on reinforcements.
- Rubbing. The rotor doesn't touch the housing, seals, inlet duct or guard mesh in any position.
- Shaft fit. The wheel, pulley, auger or coupling half is seated tightly, with no play and no chipped keyway.
- Stable speed. The drive holds its frequency: the belt doesn't slip, the variable-frequency drive doesn't wander, the load is steady.
- Misalignment. On a machine joined by a coupling, shaft alignment is done before balancing, not after.
We say this plainly here because it saves you money. Balancing only removes the vibration produced by an uneven distribution of mass around the rotation axis. It won't remove bearing knock, vibration from shaft misalignment, or the 'comb' of harmonic-multiple frequencies produced by loose fasteners — not with any weight.
Sources: Balanset-1A operation manual
Rotor cleanliness: dirt comes off right during the runs
A dirty rotor balances poorly not because the dirt is heavy, but because it isn't constant. A layer of built-up dust, product, scale or wet material clings to the blades unevenly and breaks off in chunks during run-up and coast-down. Every such loss changes the unbalance by a few grams, and the instrument sees a machine that's become a different one between two runs.
In practice it looks like this: the trial weight gave a clear response, the software calculated the correction, you installed the weights, and the check run showed vibration no lower than at the start. The engineer adds a trim weight (a small refining one), and the level drifts again. That isn't a calculation error. It's a chunk of build-up that broke off inside the exhaust fan or the fan on a dusty section.
So plan cleaning before balancing, not after. Wash or scrape the impeller, remove the film from the blades all the way around, clear the buildup off the hub and the back of the disc. If you clean the wheel only partway, you've created a new unbalance yourself, so clean either everything or nothing.
Erosion behaves differently, but with a similar outcome. An abrasive stream wears the blades unevenly, and after balancing the vibration level starts creeping up on its own. Balancing here honestly removes the vibration today rather than solving the underlying problem. If an impeller is worn noticeably and unevenly, replacing it is cheaper than sending an engineer out every quarter.
Sometimes a shutdown for cleaning costs more than the balancing itself, and you decide to balance 'as is.' That's done too, and we say so plainly: the level will come down, but the result only lasts until the next noticeable build-up. Record the before-and-after numbers so you have something to compare against a month later.
Access: sensor mounting spots, the tachometer marker, correction planes
A spot for a vibration sensor at each bearing
The sensor mounts on the bearing housing, as close to the bearing itself as possible, with its sensing axis radial, usually horizontal. The mounting has to be rigid: a magnet on a clean, flat spot, or an M4 stud. The sensor is compact, up to 40 grams, and needs a bare-metal patch roughly 30 by 30 mm, free of paint, rust and oil. A cover, guard mesh or thin sheet metal won't do — they produce vibration of their own.
A spot for the reflective marker
The laser phase sensor reads a marker made of reflective tape stuck to the shaft, hub or coupling half. Two things are needed: a clean, dry surface for the tape, and a clear line of sight from the tripod to the marker with the guard closed. Decide in advance where the magnetic tripod will stand and whether it blocks the walkway.
Access to the correction planes
You need to be able to reach the weight-installation points with the rotor stopped, through a hatch or a removed guard, without disassembling the assembly. While you're at it, count the fixed positions: the number of blades, bolt holes or spokes. From these, the software outputs not an abstract angle but a position number and mass, so you can't get the reference direction wrong.
A spot for the laptop, module and cables
You need a flat table or stand near the bearings for the laptop and the two-channel USB module to sit on. Sensor cables have to reach both bearings without running across rotating parts or blocking the walkway. In a loud or hot spot, mention it in advance — the engineer needs to watch the graph, not hold a laptop in the air.
Check access physically, not from a drawing. 'There's a hatch there' and an open hatch with the bolts already backed out describe two different states of the machine. If a hatch has been welded shut and the guard bolts are seized, say so in advance, and we'll come with a different plan.
Sources: Balanset-1A operation manual · Balanset-1A manufacturer specification
Runs, power and tools: how many stops to plan for
On-site balancing is made up of runs, not measurements. The measurement itself takes minutes; the stops are what eat up the time: waiting for the rotor to fully stop, installing or removing the weight, closing the guard, restarting the machine and getting back to the same operating mode.
Count it this way. Balancing in one plane: an initial run, a trial-weight run, a check run. Three runs minimum. Balancing in two planes: an initial run, two trial runs, a check run. Four minimum. Add one or two trim-balancing runs if you don't land on the target value the first time, and you get exactly the 3–6 runs you need to agree with process engineers in advance.
All measurements are taken at a constant speed and one operating mode. If you change the damper position, the load or the temperature between runs, you're comparing two different machines, and the previous data is reset. Fix the operating mode in advance and record it in the report.
The operator controls the runs, not the visiting engineer. Agree in advance who that is, where they'll be, and how you'll stay in contact with them: direct line of sight, radio or phone. Half the time lost on a visit goes into finding the person with the key to the control panel.
- 220 V power within 5–10 meters of the bearings. If the mains quality is poor, the engineer will switch to the laptop's battery, but it's better to know that in advance.
- Working light on the platform and inside the housing, so the correction plane and position markings are visible.
- Mechanic's tools: wrenches for the guard and foot bolts, a drill, if the correction is done by removing material.
- Material for the weights: steel plates, washers, bolts of the right length. A weight is fastened as securely as a permanent one, from the very first run.
- Welding and a welder, if the weights are being welded on. Arrange hot work clearance separately in advance — it's a common cause of losing half a day.
- Scales on hand. The mass of the trial and correction weights goes in as the actual measured value, not 'about ten grams.'
A trial weight is sized so the running-speed amplitude changes by at least 20–30%, or the phase by at least 20–30°. If there's no response, the weight is increased and another run is made. Build that margin into the window: an announced 'exactly three runs' sometimes turns into five.
Sources: Balanset-1A operation manual
People and safety: who's responsible for what
Balancing happens on a running machine with the guard open or partly removed, so organizing the work matters here more than the instrument does. Name two people in advance and introduce them to the engineer in the first few minutes: the person responsible for work safety, and the person responsible for starting and stopping. These can be different people, and both need to be on site the whole time.
The guard is removed and replaced only with the rotor stopped. While someone is working at the correction plane, the start control has to be physically locked out — a verbal agreement isn't enough. The key or lockout tag stays with the person working inside, and no one else.
Fastening the weights is also a safety matter, not just an accuracy one. A trial weight is held with a bolt, a clamp or a tack weld. Tape, putty, a magnet or a cable tie won't do for any run: a weight that comes loose at operating speed will go through the guard. And the weight itself must not touch stationary parts or overload its mounting point.
- A work permit or authorization is arranged before the visit, not on the day of the work.
- A person responsible for work safety is named, and knows about the removed guard.
- A person responsible for starting and stopping is named, on site and reachable the whole time.
- The lockout scheme is clear: who locks it, who unlocks it, where the key or tag is.
- PPE on everyone involved: helmet, safety glasses, gloves, hearing protection near a loud machine.
- Hot work is cleared separately, if the correction weights are being welded on.
- A communication method between the site and the control panel is agreed: direct line of sight, radio or phone.
- It's clear where people step back to during a run, and where the danger zone is marked.
The engineer has the right to stop work if the start control can't be locked out, or if the guard is being removed on a rotor that's still turning. That isn't a formality or something to negotiate: you don't balance under an open hatch on a fan that's running.
Machine data and a draft report
Machine data isn't needed for paperwork's sake. Every figure answers a specific question before the visit: what fasteners to bring, how many correction planes to plan for, what trial weight to use, and what criterion to use for calling the job done. Send it in advance, and you'll save the first hour of the visit, which would otherwise go into measuring with a tape and calling the chief mechanic's office.
We'll separately ask for photos and a short video. Photos of the bearings show whether a magnet will hold and where the cable will run. A photo of the correction plane shows how many fixed positions there are. A video with sound often reveals things no email mentions: a whining bearing, a rhythmic knock, the sound of rubbing.
- The machine's designation and position on your own scheme, so the report matches your documentation.
- Measurement points with names and directions: bearing 1 horizontal, bearing 1 vertical, and so on.
- The operating mode during the readings: speed, load, damper or valve position, temperature.
- The measured quantity and frequency band for assessment: mm/s RMS in the 10–1000 Hz band as a working benchmark.
- The target vibration value or the balance quality grade G you want to reach.
- Who signs the report on your side, and in what form you need it.
| What to send | Why it's needed |
|---|---|
| Nameplate and actual speed | To find the running-speed component in the spectrum (the breakdown of vibration by frequency), choose the measurement mode, and assess proximity to resonance |
| Drive power and machine type | To choose the applicable group and overall-vibration assessment zone in mm/s RMS (root mean square) |
| Rotor mass | To calculate the tolerance by balance quality grade G (the residual-unbalance standard) and estimate the trial-weight mass |
| Type of supports and foundation: rigid or compliant | To choose the correct assessment zones. A compliant foundation allows a higher level than a rigid one |
| Rotor layout: between bearings or overhung, length and diameter | To decide whether one correction plane or two is needed, before the visit |
| Number of blades, holes or spokes | To work in fixed-position mode and not get the angle-reference direction wrong |
| History of repairs, wheel replacements and prior balancing | To understand whether the problem is recurring, rather than hunting for the cause from scratch |
| Photos of the rotor, both bearings and the correction planes | To check access and choose sensor fasteners in advance |
| A short video of it running, with sound | To hear a bearing, rubbing or a loose fit before the first reading |
Fix the frequency band, measurement points, operating mode and the exact part and edition of the standard before work starts, if the result is going into acceptance under a contract. Use ISO 20816 and ISO 21940-11 as a working reference and check applicability to your own machine: there are exceptions by power, speed and machine type.
Sources: ISO 20816-1:2016 · ISO 21940-11:2016
What to prepare, why, and what happens if you skip it
| What to prepare | Why it's needed | What happens if you don't |
|---|---|---|
| Sound bearings, bolted-down feet, an intact frame | Keep the linearity the correction calculation depends on | Readings jump around, the influence coefficient comes out random, weights land in the wrong place. The visit gets postponed until after repair |
| A clean impeller | The result has to repeat from run to run | Build-up breaks off during the runs, vibration comes back after correction, and you pay for work that doesn't hold |
| Cleaned mounting spots for the sensors on the bearing housings | A rigid mount where the load actually passes through | A reading off the cover or off paint gives unstable numbers, and the whole decision rests on bad data |
| A spot for the reflective marker and a clear sightline for the laser | No reference marker means no rotation frequency and no phase, and therefore no running-speed component | Balancing is physically impossible. The engineer works as a vibrometer and leaves |
| Access to the correction planes with the rotor stopped | Installing the trial and correction weight without disassembling the assembly | Either on-site disassembly, or removing the rotor and balancing it on a machine. A different budget and different timeline |
| An agreed window for 3–6 runs with stops | The method is built so there's no calculation without trial and check runs | The work gets cut off halfway, the machine is left with the trial weight on, and everything starts over on the next visit |
| The same operating mode for every run | Comparable readings you can actually compare | Data from earlier runs is reset, the number of attempts grows, and the window runs out before the result does |
| 220 V power, lighting, tools and material for the weights | Installing the weight exactly where the calculation shows, at the same radius | The correction goes wherever it can, accuracy drops, and the number of runs grows |
| A work permit, start lockout, responsible people | The work happens on a running machine with the guard removed | Work doesn't start at all, and both sides lose the day |
| Machine data and a draft report | Calculating the tolerance, choosing the number of planes, and issuing a document that matches your paperwork | The first hour goes into measuring by hand, and the report ends up finished by email a week later |
This table is easy to forward to the section mechanic as it stands. The right-hand column usually convinces better than the left one.
When work gets postponed or stopped, and how to arrange a visit
An honest conversation before the visit is cheaper than an honest conversation on site. There are conditions under which the engineer won't start the work, or will stop it partway through, and it's better to check them against this list in advance.
If you need a visit
Send the completed checklist, photos of the rotor and bearings, a short video of it running, and the machine data. AXILINE's experienced engineers will look them over before the visit and tell you plainly: balancing will help here, or a repair and shaft alignment come first. That kind of review before the visit saves you a shift more often than the balancing itself does.
If you're doing it yourself
The Balanset-1A is the very instrument we use for field work: two accelerometers on the bearing housings, a laser phase sensor reading the reflective marker, a two-channel USB module, and Windows software. It measures speed, and the amplitude and phase of overall vibration and the running-speed component, and shows a spectrum and the time waveform. It balances in one and two planes, calculates the tolerance by grade G, splits the weight across fixed positions, and stores results in an archive for the report. The instruments are designed, built and taken out to sites by the same engineers, so questions about method go to people who have balanced a machine like yours, not to a support script.
- The mechanics aren't sound. Critical bearing play, a rubbing rotor, a crack in the frame, a loosened anchor. Repair first, then balance.
- The machine isn't bolted to its base. It sits on the floor or on shims with no anchors and lifts under vibration. Bolt it down, then balance.
- Speed is unstable. The belt slips, the drive doesn't hold its frequency, the load wanders. Readings at a varying speed aren't valid for the calculation.
- The operating speed falls in a resonance zone: the rotation frequency coincides with a natural frequency of the structure, and vibration spikes sharply. The phase of the running-speed component shifts from run to run, and the result doesn't repeat. Either the mode or the mounting conditions need to change, or balancing is pointless.
- No access to the correction plane. There's nowhere to put the weight without disassembly. Either disassemble on site, or remove the rotor and balance it on a machine.
- No clearance for runs. No work permit, no one responsible for starting, no way to lock out the panel. The work gets postponed.
- The machine can't be stopped the needed number of times. A continuous process with no window. Look for another window, usually a maintenance shutdown.
- Site conditions are outside the operating range. The instrument works at +5 to +50 °C and up to 85% humidity without condensation. Frost, rain on an open platform, or condensation dripping down are reasons to postpone.
- The vibration isn't running-speed in nature. Aerodynamic or electromagnetic force grows in proportion to speed, while a weight's centrifugal force grows with its square. That kind of vibration can only be compensated at one specific operating mode, and we say so before the work, not after.
- The rotor is flexible and operates above its first critical speed — the speed at which the rotor starts bowing noticeably. That calls for a different method and a different conversation.
If you've gone through the checklist and something doesn't add up, don't cancel the visit quietly. Write in and say exactly what isn't working: the plan often changes on site without losing a day. The software can recalculate an inaccessible second correction plane onto accessible ones, and instead of an angle with a protractor, you can work by blade number.
Sources: Balanset-1A manufacturer specification · Balanset-1A operation manual
Frequently asked questions
How long does on-site balancing take if we've prepared everything?
Count time in runs and stops, not measurements. The reading itself at the operating mode takes minutes, while each stop, until rotation fully ends, plus installing the weight and closing the guard, makes up the bulk of the schedule. On a prepared machine, plan for 3–6 runs: three for balancing in one plane, four for two planes, plus one or two for trim balancing if you don't land on target the first time. On a large, high-inertia machine the coast-down (free rotation after power-off until it fully stops) itself is long, and that needs to go into the window too.
Does the impeller always have to come off and go to a balancing machine?
In most cases, no. The point of on-site balancing is that the rotor runs in its own bearings, at operating speed, together with its own frame and drive, and you get a result for exactly this machine. Removing the rotor is needed when there's no access to the correction plane without disassembly, when the rotor is flexible, when its geometry is already damaged, or when the machine can't be started the required number of times.
Can you balance if the rotor can't be cleaned?
Technically yes, and it's sometimes done that way when a shutdown for cleaning costs more than the balancing itself. But the result will hold only until the next noticeable build-up or debris loss, and scatter in the readings during the runs may raise the number of attempts needed. We say so before starting work and record before-and-after numbers so you can see how long the effect held.
Who should start and stop the machine during the work?
Your operator, authorized under your own rules. The visiting engineer works with the instrument and the weights, not the control panel. Name two people in advance: the person responsible for work safety and the person responsible for starting and stopping. Both need to be on site the whole time, and reachable: direct line of sight, radio or phone.
What if there's no 220 V outlet near the machine?
The measuring module runs on USB power from the laptop, so a short measurement window can be run off the battery. The same solution applies when the local mains is poor quality and causes heavy interference. But the battery usually won't last a full shift, and lighting, a drill or welding won't run off it, so bring an extension cord and a distribution board to the site anyway.
We want to know before the visit whether balancing will even help. What should we send?
Nameplate and actual speed, drive power, rotor mass, type of supports and foundation, the rotor's layout relative to its supports, the number of blades or weight holes, and the repair history. Add photos of both bearing housings, the correction planes, and a short video of it running, with sound. If you have a vibration reading, send the overall level and the running-speed component with the measurement points and directions noted. From that set, it's usually already clear whether this is a balancing job or a repair-and-alignment one.
Related content
How to choose a balancing and vibration diagnostics contractor: questions, red flags, contract
Ask three things: what you measure with and how many channels, whether you measure phase and speed, and what you'll do if the cause isn't unbalance. A specialist will answer with a two-channel analyzer with a phase sensor keyed to a mark on the shaft, comparing overall vibration against the 1x running-speed component — the part of the vibration that repeats exactly once per shaft revolution — and that they won't balance if the 1x share is small. Someone with a plain vibrometer promises a result before the measurement and won't show you before-and-after data. A method's limits, stated out loud, are more reliable than any 'we'll fix everything' guarantee.
Three tolerances in balancing: what “within norm” actually means
The word “tolerance” in balancing covers three independent things. First: the residual 1x running-speed component (the vibration at rotation frequency that imbalance creates) is below the target value you entered yourself in the instrument's software. Second: the machine's overall vibration, in mm/s RMS over the 10-1000 Hz band, assessed by zones A-D under ISO 20816 on the non-rotating parts. Third: the rotor's residual imbalance, in g·mm or g·mm/kg, by balance quality grades G under ISO 21940-11. None of the three confirms the other two.
Balancing production-line equipment at the point of operation
Yes, we balance production-equipment rotors on site. Three conditions are needed: the rotor starts up at running speed and holds it steadily, there's access to the bearing supports for sensors and to a correction plane for weights, and the once-per-turn component 1x — vibration at the rotor's rotation frequency, which is exactly what unbalance creates — accounts for most of the vibration. If 1x is small and the machine still shakes, the cause is in the fixings, misalignment, the bearings or resonance, and we'll say so before any work starts. In food, pharmaceutical and chemical production we work without hot work: bolted stainless-steel weights and studs, or removing metal by drilling in allowed locations.
Describe your equipment and the problem
We'll answer your questions, clarify the details, and let you know what's needed for an estimate and a visit.